The Foxes walk upon it

"And at the same time they will come to understand and see that it is the Rebbe who runs this world, until he comes to take us out of galus."

The author of the above statement is one Rabbi Boruch Shalom Cunin. Rabbi Cunin was personally appointed shaliach to the West Coast of the United States by Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the late leader of the Lubavitch movement.This statement is astonishing in its sadness and terrifying in its explicitness.

I would like to contrast this statement to one of Zecharia that many have the minhag of saying at the end of the Aleinu.

ט והיה יהוה למלך, על-כל-הארץ; ביום ההוא, יהיה יהוה אחד--ושמו אחד.
"And it will be that the Lrd is King over all the Land, on that day he and his name will be unified"
This is the idea of Yimos Hamashiach according to Zechariah . It is a period of time when the entire world recognizes the reality of the Kingship of G and serves him accordingly. His name and He will be unified, in other words the entire world will desire to serve only the true conception of G. No longer will man serve the desires of his heart nor the lusts of his eyes. Currently there are those that serve G and those that serve a distorted notion of G, I believe that the unification at the end of the pasuk refers to an era when there will be no more distortions of the real Name of G and everyone will serve the Creator of Heaven and Earth.

The statement of Rabbi Cunin is disturbing in its fundamental denial of G and its sheer brazenness. What Rabbi Cunin is saying has reached a new pinnacle in heresy. " At the same time", similar phraseology as Zecharia, Cunin is longing for the day when," they will come to understand", presumably he means the world, this would I suppose include those who accept the 13 Ikkarim," that it is the Rebbe who runs the world until he comes to take us out of Galus".

Rabbi Cunin has replaced G with the Rebbe, he longs for the day that mankind will pervert themselves into believing that Menachem Mendel Schneerson is G, and at that time the Rebbi will return and save Rabbi Cunin from Galus.


So it is quite clear. The G of Israel is not the G of Rabbi Cunin. This is sad enough. It is a tragedy that one person has a faulty idea but this tragedy is magnified when we consider who he is. Rabbi Cunin is in the position to influence thousands upon thousands of Jews via his work as the head of Chabad in California and Nevada. This is the real tragedy, not only does Rabbi Cunin believe the most despicable of beliefs but he is a teacher and advisor to thousands of Jews. I do not know if Rabbi Cunin is alone in his belief, I pray that he is although I suspect he is not. This makes a clear statement about his movement however. Any movement that will allow one of its leaders to harbor these ideas is clearly not dedicated to the ikkarim. The presence of what would seem like authentic Jewish leaders declaring these perversions is the real tragedy of our time.

The crown is fallen from our head; woe unto us! for we have sinned.For this our heart is faint, for these things our eyes are dim;For the mountain of Zion, which is desolate, the foxes walk upon it.

The Chazon Ish brain surgery, Rav Charlop and his "telekenisis" and other fantastic tales of bizui haTorah

I recently met a very intelligent fellow who told over two very fantastic "stories" regarding gedolim and seemingly miraculous events. This gent proceeded to question the rational philosophy espoused by my yeshiva based on these two fantastic stories.I had heard the first story many years ago and it remains unverified and without a source to this day. Recently I was informed ( although I have yet to see it myself) that this story is included in the biography of the Chazon Ish ( Harav Avrohom Yishaya Karelitz) which was published by a very prominent religious publishing house. The second story was new to me and I have been unable to find it anywhere. Again it is unverified and unsourced. I am writing this not in response to the stories themselves but rather as a reaction to the way people view these stories . I would like to preface by saying that this is in no way an attack on the individual who told me these stories. Indeed he was doing nothing less than seeking the truth and he should be commended for it.This is however, a response to the method of thinking that these stories are used to support.













(I will present the stories as I have heard them, If there are sources and or corrections in the story please make me aware of them.)






Story A- The Chazon Ish- brain surgeon.






The story goes as follows.






There was a patient in Israel who had a large brain tumor that required surgery of a very difficult nature in order to be cured. No surgeons were able to figure out exactly how to execute the surgery.The patient was distraught at the possibility that modern medicine could not save him and he sought guidance from the gaon Rav Avrahom Yeshaya Karelitz , the Chazon Ish. As the story goes the Chazon Ish examined the patient and using his knowledge of mesechet Chullin was able to plot the appropriate method for surgery.






Story B- Rav Charlop and his telekinetic abilities






The second story as told by this individual :






During the first World War Rav Charlop was mithpalel at the kotel. Suddenly he had a vision of Rav Avraham Yitzchak Hacohen Kook learning in London. ( Apparently Rav Kook was residing in England during the hostilities.) Not only did Rav Charlop envision Rav Kook learning but he was also aware of the sugya that he was learning at that very moment. Rav Charlop was purported to have told this to Rav Kook sometime later when they were reunited.











The problem I have with both of these stories is as follows. Let us assume that both stories are real. It is possible that the Chazon Ish was able to devise a way to remove a brain tumor. Rav Karelitz was a tremendous chacham and it is possible that he was aware of brain function and physiology enough to help the medical professionals. Perhaps. It could also be logically argued that the second story was a result of Rav Charlops tremendous understanding of the mind and thoughts or Rav Kook which led him to think of what Rav Kook was learning. Again, it is theoretically possible. My problem is thus: as I said it could be that both of these stories occured in some form, somehow. However, the emphasis and weight that is put into these stories along with the inevitable questioning of rationality that follows is the problem.





When these stories were told to me they were told in order to somehow prove to me that there are magical phenomena at work in the world. Miraculous occurences which somehow should call into question my world view. The purported surgery was a function of the fact that " everything is in the Torah" and so therefore a chacham will know science better than the scientist. ( I am still unclear as to exactly what the Rav Charlop story was supposed to prove).This is my problem. When we allow fantastical stories to creep into our minds and give them as much weight as rational investigation and mesora then we are degrading the very Torah which we claim to adhere to. I dont care one iota whether Rav Charlop knew what Rav Kook was learning or whether the Chazon Ish knew brain surgery. To the adherent of the mesora it is irrelevant.

There is another point that I am always astonished by aside from the sheer irrelevance to the mesora. These stories are nothing less than bizui haTorah and bizui talmidei chachamim. The fact that there are stories being told about chachmei hamesorah and their seemingly magical powers is defining what the mesora and chachamim are to the people who peddle these fables.In short, the mesorah( to those who adhere to these stories) is some magical tradition that allows those who master it to perform miracles and break the rules of science . In fact the mesorah is a rational worldview which accepts cause and effect as real and denies stupidity and foolishness. To imply that the Torah is a magic " realm" is to completly degrade the essence of the Torah. As the verse in Deuteronomy states(Chap.4 verse10)

וּשְׁמַרְתֶּם, וַעֲשִׂיתֶם--כִּי הִוא חָכְמַתְכֶם וּבִינַתְכֶם, לְעֵינֵי הָעַמִּים: אֲשֶׁר יִשְׁמְעוּן, אֵת כָּל-הַחֻקִּים הָאֵלֶּה, וְאָמְרוּ רַק עַם-חָכָם וְנָבוֹן, הַגּוֹי הַגָּדוֹל הַזֶּה
" and you shall guard them to perform them for they are your wisdom and understanding in they eyes of the nations that will hear all of these statutes and declare ' surely a wise and discerning and great nation this is".

The mesora and its masters are not magicians and anyone who implies the opposite should go ask one of them and they will instruct you to examine your actions and return to the system of reality.